“We skipped the light fandango
Turned cartwheels ‘cross the floor
I was feeling kind of seasick
The crowd called out for more…”
Above are the opening lines of “A Whiter Shade Of Pale”, first released by Procol Harum on the cusp of the ‘psychedelic’ era in 1967, since when it’s been a staple of nostalgia-based radio shows and stations playing golden oldies. It’s had more airplay recently due to the sad death of the lead vocalist of Procol Harum, Gary Brooker.
He re-formed the band several times after their initial break-up, with various changes of personnel and also toured and recorded with the ‘supergroup’ Bill Wyman’s Rhythm Kings. He played in Eric Clapton’s band, recorded solo albums and was also one of the rock music stalwarts who appeared on the memorable 2002 “Concert For George” tribute for George Harrison at the Albert Hall.
So, there were many more strings to Gary’s bow (and keys to his piano!) than being the unmistakeable voice on the classic pop song.
It was a UK No1 and a US A No5, so would have earned the songwriters Keith Reid and Gary Brooker a substantial amount from record sales and TV and film soundtracks.
It’s said in the entertainment world, “Where there’s a hit there’s a writ”, and Procol’s organist Matthew Fisher waited until 2008 to claim a co-writer credit for his distinctive Bach-style organ intro to the song. Musicians might describe it as a feud over a fugue!
He won the case and was awarded a 40% share in the song from 2008 onwards.
“A Whiter Shade Of Pale” has never dated because, unlike many ‘ I love you’ or ‘ You broke my heart’ romantic ballads which have remained popular from one generation to the next, it contains enigmatic lyrics that are open to individual interpretation.
Members of Procol Harum have given various explanations since they recorded it, many of which have been disputed by other band members!
I suppose we’ll never really know what the song’s about.
However, I have another question – one that’s never been asked or answered as far as I know. What, exactly, is a Procol Harum?